WIUM Tristates Public Radio

Immigration Courts 'Operating In Crisis Mode,' Judges Say

Feb 23, 2015
Originally published on February 23, 2015 12:54 pm

As Congress debates the fate of President Obama's immigration policies, the nation's immigration court system is bogged down in delays exacerbated by the flood of unaccompanied minors who crossed the southern border last summer.

The administration made it a priority for those cases to be heard immediately. As a result, hundreds of thousands of other cases have been delayed until as late as 2019.

Even before this past summer's surge of unaccompanied minors seeking asylum, the immigration courts were already clogged, says Judge Dana Leigh Marks, president of the National Association of Immigration Judges.

"What is an adjective that describes crisis squared?" she asks. "Crisis times crisis. We have been operating in crisis mode for years."

There were too many cases for too few judges, and adding in the cases of the unaccompanied minors only made matters worse. There are currently more than 429,000 cases pending in the courts with just 223 judges.

Marks, who does not speak for the Justice Department, says it's no longer the situation that the first case in is the first case heard.

"Now it's the last cases that come in, the recent border crossers — those cases are moved as it is to the front of the line," she says. "And that displaces cases that have been waiting on the dockets for months or years depending on the court location."

Lance Curtright, a San Antonio immigration lawyer, says his firm has hundreds of clients who are in limbo.

"Some of my clients would qualify to get a green card. They can't get it, so their pathway to citizenship is being delayed," he says. "The anxiety that they live through is just remarkable because they don't know if they are going to be deported or not. It trickles down to their family members, their spouses and their children as well."

This story is familiar to Enrique Arevalo, an immigration attorney based in Pasadena, Calif. He says some of his clients have been waiting years to legalize their status and need only a 15-minute hearing for a judge to finally sign off on their cases. But now they're told they'll have to wait indefinitely.

Arevalo says there's a simple solution.

"Just like they hire more Border Patrol persons to patrol the border, they should hire more immigration judges to make this a more expeditious process," he says. "So, expeditious justice I don't think really exists when it comes to immigration law."

The Obama administration has proposed hiring more immigration judges, but that request is hung up in Congress.

As the delays mount, the immigration court system faces other problems. By prioritizing the cases of the unaccompanied minors, the administration fast-tracked their court hearings, creating a shortage of lawyers as legal service providers are swamped with cases.

According to federal records collected by Syracuse University, there are roughly 60,000 unaccompanied minors in the courts. Less than 30 percent have lawyers. Without a lawyer, a minor has a very slim chance of staying in this country.

And even those with a lawyer face another potential obstacle.

"Many of the children are actually never properly notified of the date when their court hearing is, and that problem has been going on for months," says Ahilan Arulanantham, an attorney with the ACLU's Immigrants' Rights Project.

He says with the fast-tracking of cases, basic administrative processes — like providing minors and their families with adequate notice of their hearings — broke down.

"In many places, what judges are doing is they are ordering the children deported, in abstentia, without them having appeared in the courtroom," he says. "And that is obviously extremely unfair when they didn't know about the court date to begin with."

Representatives of legal service providers have met with administration officials to discuss the problems of adequately notifying minors of their court dates. But no immediate solutions were offered.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

Congress and the courts are debating big questions about President Obama's immigration policy. This story examines a more basic question. It's how to properly handle people who face possible removal from this country. Immigration courts, which are supposed to hear their cases, are overloaded. Last year, the White House prioritized the cases of unaccompanied minors crossing the Southern border. That sounds good. But as a result, hundreds of thousands of other cases are delayed. Some won't be heard until 2019. NPR's Richard Gonzales reports.

RICHARD GONZALES, BYLINE: Even before this past summer's surge of unaccompanied minors seeking asylum, the immigration courts were already clogged, says Judge Dana Leigh Marks, president of the National Association of Immigration Judges.

DANA LEIGH MARKS: What is an adjective that describes crisis squared? Crisis times crisis. We have been operating in crisis mode for years.

GONZALES: There were too many cases for too few judges. Adding in the cases of the unaccompanied minors only made matters worse. There are currently more than 429,000 cases pending in the courts with just 223 judges. Judge Marks, who does not speak for the Department of Justice, says it's no longer a matter of first case in is the first case heard.

MARKS: Now it's the last cases that come in - the recent border crossers - those cases are moved as it is to the front of the line. And that displaces cases that have been waiting on the dockets for months or years depending on the court location.

GONZALES: What's that mean? Just ask San Antonio immigration lawyer Lance Curtright. He says his firm has hundreds of clients who are in limbo.

MARKS: Some of my clients could qualify to get a green card. They can't get it, so their pathway to citizenship is being delayed. The anxiety that they live through is just remarkable because they don't know if they're going to be deported or not. It trickles down to their family members, their spouses and their children as well.

GONZALES: The story is familiar to Pasadena-based immigration attorney Enrique Arevalo. He says he has clients who have been waiting for years to legalize their status and need only a 15-minute hearing for a judge to finally sign off on their cases. But now they're told they'll have to wait indefinitely. Arevalo says there's a simple solution.

ENRIQUE AREVALO: Just like they hire more border patrol persons to patrol the border, they should hire more immigration judges to make this a more expeditious process, you know? So expeditious justice I don't think really exists when it comes to immigration law.

GONZALES: The Obama administration has proposed hiring more immigration judges, but that request is hung up in Congress. As the delays mount, the immigration court system faces other problems. By prioritizing the cases of the unaccompanied minors, the administration fast-tracked their court hearings; that's helped create a shortage of lawyers as legal service providers are swamped with cases. According to federal records collected by Syracuse University, there are roughly 60,000 unaccompanied minors in the courts. Less than 30 percent have lawyers. Without a lawyer, a minor has a very slim chance of staying in this country. And even those with a lawyer face another potential obstacle.

AHILAN ARULANANTHAM: Many of the children are actually never properly notified of the date when their court hearing is. And that problem has been going on for months.

GONZALES: Ahilan Arulanantham is an attorney with the ACLU's Immigrants' Rights Project. He says with the fast-tracking of cases, basic administrative processes broke down, like providing the minors and their families with adequate notice of their hearings.

ARULANANTHAM: In many places, what judges are doing is they are ordering the children deported, in absentia, without them having appeared in the courtroom. And that is obviously extremely unfair when they didn't know about the court date to begin with.

GONZALES: Representatives of legal service providers have met with administration officials to discuss the problems of adequately notifying minors of their court dates, but no immediate solutions were offered. Richard Gonzales, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.