Most Active Stories
Tue April 30, 2013
He Helped Discover Evolution, And Then Became Extinct
Originally published on Mon May 6, 2013 2:27 pm
Ask most folks who came up with the theory of evolution, and they'll tell you it was Charles Darwin.
In fact, Alfred Russel Wallace, another British naturalist, was a co-discoverer of the theory — though Darwin has gotten most of the credit. Wallace died 100 years ago this year.
Wallace developed some of his most important ideas about natural selection during an eight-year expedition to what was then the Dutch East Indies — modern-day Indonesia — to observe wildlife and collect specimens. Few places on earth can rival this vast archipelago's tremendous diversity of plant and animal life.
Wallace collected more than 100,000 insect, bird and animal specimens, which he gave to British museums.
By 1855, Wallace had come to the conclusion that living things evolve. But he didn't figure out how until one night three years later. He was on the island of Halmahera, ill with a fever, when it came to him: Animals evolve by adapting to their environment.
As soon as he could, Wallace wrote his theory down in a closely argued, eight- or nine-page paper, says Tony Whitten, a Wallace expert with British-based Flora & Fauna International.
"He sent that to Darwin, as an older mentor, if you like, to have a peer review before publication," Whitten says.
Darwin had reached the same conclusion years earlier, and Wallace's letter spurred him to act. The two men published a joint paper in 1858, arguing the theory of evolution and natural selection. It shook mankind's assumptions about its origins, which were heavily influenced by religion.
The following year, Darwin published his book On the Origin of Species and rose to fame. Wallace, ultimately, faded into obscurity.
Sulawesi And Survival Of The Fittest
But at the time, Wallace was still refining his ideas about natural selection — and had landed on what is now Indonesia's island of Sulawesi, a place where most of the animals there existed no place else on earth.
Today, Sulawesi's natural abundance has been severely depleted. Many of its unique species are close to extinction in the wild, found only in nature preserves.
The high point for Wallace's explorations on Sulawesi was the search for a bird called the maleo, which exists in nature only on the island.
In Wallace's footsteps, I recently went in search of the bird at the Bogani Nani Wartabone National Park. I walked through a dense, misty highland forest, full of luxuriant fan palms and bubbling hot springs, amid the constant chatter of birds and insects.
At one point, we spotted two male maleos, calling to their mates, with an eerie, trilling sound. The birds are somewhere between a chicken and a turkey in size, with black feathers and a salmon-colored breast.
In his book The Malay Archipelago, Wallace wrote that students of natural history should avoid thinking of animal behavior as "fixed points." He argued that this has "the bad effect of stifling inquiry into the nature and causes of 'instincts and habits.' " Wallace's insatiably curious mind was constantly thinking about how animals' behavior reflected their changing natural surroundings.
For example, Wallace observed that maleos have adapted so perfectly to the environment that they even use Sulawesi's geology to survive. Instead of sitting on their eggs like hens, maleos use geothermal energy to incubate them. They dig into the earth, which is heated by hot springs. They can sense where the temperature is just 86 to 97 degrees, and that's where they lay their eggs.
At the park's hatchery, ranger Max Lela showed us a downy, three-day-old maleo chick. We could see that unlike other species similar to it, the maleo has webbing between three of its claws. Wallace believed that maleos had developed this webbing to help them dig into the earth and bury their eggs.
Lela says that after eight weeks, the buried eggs hatch and the maleo chicks struggle up through the dirt and immediately fly away. That keeps them safe from local predators such as the monitor lizard.
"After reaching the surface, they will stop and then shake their wings and body because they are covered with dirt," Lela says. "But then they can walk and fly right away, without any parental training."
Lela puts the little chick in my hand. It wobbles for a second, and then flies off into a nearby tree — no small feat for a three-day-old bird.
Perhaps Wallace's greatest contribution to the theory of natural selection was simply to ask: Why do we find this animal in this place?
He realized that just as animals are shaped by where they live, regions can also be defined by the animals that live there.
He noticed, for example, that the maleo is related to species found in Australia, but not in Asia, not even on the island of Borneo just a few miles to the west. Even non-experts may observe that there are no elephants or rhinoceroses in Australia, and no kangaroos or koalas in Asia.
Whitten, Fauna & Flora International's Asia-Pacific regional director, says Wallace concluded that Sulawesi was located on some sort of boundary line that separates different biological regions.
"Clearly this was a transition between the Asian world and the Australian world," Whitten says. "And so came the thought of this line that could be drawn between Borneo and Sulawesi, that would separate the Asian fauna from the Australian fauna."
Wallace didn't know it at the time, but that line is actually the divide between two continental shelves. The line is now called the Wallace Line, and the transitional region around it is called Wallacea.
Wallace believed that Sulawesi is unique because most of the animals that live here are not found anywhere else on earth.
He concluded that these animals had been on this island isolated from other species for a very long time, and slowly evolved into new species.
Sulawesi naturalist John Tasirin says that Wallace found that 64 percent of mammals on Sulawesi are unique to the island. However, if you subtract bats — which are highly migratory mammals — from that figure, it jumps to 86 percent.
Tasirin says that Wallace saw the island's natural history in terms of how species had migrated to new environments on the island, adapted to them, and then evolved.
"You can see the movement of the animals. And when they move, suddenly they become a new species," Tasirin says, adding that it's not exactly "suddenly" but more like 3,000 or 6,000 years.
Foretelling Future Threats
Biodiversity provides the raw material for natural selection to work on. It also allowed Wallace to compare and contrast the differences among many species — differences as subtle as the graceful curve of a butterfly's wing.
Whitten says Wallace marveled at the variety of life on earth, even as he mourned man's effect on it.
"He just wondered how could it possibly be that ... we celebrate creation, in whatever way you want to understand that, and yet destroy it at the same time; [and that] just was so awful that we should all work to try to conserve that biodiversity," Whitten says.
As Wallace's eyes observed life around him, his mind roamed millions of years back in time, to imagine the birth of islands and continents. He also peered into the future. Back in England in 1863, he wrote:
"Future ages will certainly look back on us as a people so immersed in the pursuit of wealth as to be blind to higher considerations."
Wallace foretold today's situation, in which Sulawesi's unique animals face extinction. He wrote that we have it within our power to save these creatures, and not let them, as he put it, "perish irrecoverably from the face of the earth, uncared for and unknown."
RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:
Few places on earth can rival the astonishing diversity of plant and animal life found in Indonesia, that collection of tropical islands stretched across a vast crescent. The abundance inspired British nationalist Alfred Russel Wallace to pen the first scientific paper arguing the theory of evolution with his far more famous co-author, Charles Darwin.
Wallace died 100 years ago this year. NPR's Anthony Kuhn takes us to the island of Sulawesi where the scientist made some of his most profound observations.
ANTHONY KUHN, BYLINE: Wallace arrived here more 150 years ago in what was then the Dutch East Indies. During his eight year expedition, he would collect over 100,000 plant and animals species. Tony Whitten with the British-based Flora and Fauna International says that on his journey, Wallace was constantly battling tropical disease and bad weather, but his mind was on other things.
TONY WHITTEN: When he was working, he would have just forgotten about the pain and the damp and the wet and the mold and he was just totally absorbed in what he was doing and just found life around him amazing.
KUHN: When Wallace landed here on Sulawesi in 1859, he had already co-authored his paper with Darwin, but he was still refining his ideas about evolution and he was fascinated to be on an island where most of the animals existed no place else on earth. Today, Sulawesi's natural abundance has been severely depleted. Many of its unique species are close to extinction in the wild.
You can only find them in nature preserves like this one. Here we have a sign board. This is the Bogani Nani Wartabone National Park. I'm looking for a bird called the maleo. Wallace's search for this bird was the high point of his explorations on Sulawesi. OK, so we're going to have to be really quiet when we approach the maleo, otherwise they're going to bolt.
We're just going to have to talk very quietly. Well, we're walking through sort of highland forest and we're lucky to be here on a day where it's very cool and misty with a light rain coming down. Wallace's observations about the maleo helped to build his understanding of evolution, but they also captured this man's limitless curiosity.
Wallace wrote that we should never be content to look at a living thing and say, oh, that's just the way it is. We should always be inquiring about how it got that way and how it's related to its environment.
MAX LELA: It's hard to find the maleo.
KUHN: With me, is park ranger Max Lela. I ask him, what does the maleo's call sound like.
LELA: (Through Translator) Maleo (unintelligible) comes in a couple. The male maleo will sound like (makes sound). Female maleo will sound like (makes sound).
KUHN: I've lost it now.
LELA: Victory, first branch.
KUHN: There they are, two male maleo's perching in a tree calling to their mates. Their size is somewhere between a chicken and a turkey, with black feathers and a salmon-colored breast. Wallace observed that maleos have adapted so perfectly to their environment that they even use Sulawesi's geology to survive. Instead of sitting on their eggs like hens, maleos use geothermal energy to incubate them.
They dig into the earth, which is heated by hot springs. They can sense where the temperature is between 86 to 97 degrees. That's where they lay their eggs. Those two in stereo, a very animated conversation. Now, we're at the park's hatchery and Lela is showing us a two-day old maleo chick. He's putting the downy little bird in my hand and this gives us a chance to see how its body has adapted to its environment.
Touching the feathers on the back of the little maleo's neck and they're very soft and downy. The maleo's feet that we're looking at right now, the legs are straight and the claws, it's got four fingers with webbing in between two of them and that's their shovel. That's what they use to dig. Lela says that after eight weeks, the buried eggs hatch.
It takes the maleo chicks about three days to struggle up through two or three feet of dirt - pecking, flapping and kicking their way out. They're able to fly away almost as soon as they reach the surface and that keeps them safe from predators.
LELA: Anthony, you can release.
KUHN: Off you go. Yes. So that bird sort of wobbled a bit on my right hand and then with a push and shove, off it flew and roosted on a tree branch. Very impressive for a three-day old bird. On Sulawesi, Wallace noticed something unusual and that is that the maleo is related to species found in Australia and the Western Pacific hundreds or thousands of miles away, but not in Asia, not even on the island of Borneo just a few miles to the west.
So Tony Whitten says Wallace drew a line on the map to separate what seemed to him to be distinct regions with different kinds of animals. That line is now called the Wallace Line and the region around it is called Wallacea.
WHITTEN: It was clearly this sort of transition between the Asian world and the Australian world. And so came the thought of this line that could be drawn between Borneo and Sulawesi that would separate the Asian fauna from the Australian fauna.
KUHN: Wallace didn't know it at the time, but his line is actually the divide between two continental shelves. Really, Wallace was just asking a simple question. Why do we find this animal in this place? At the Tasikoki Wildlife Rescue and Education Center, we meet up with local naturalist John Tasirin. And Tasirin says that you can see that process happening right here on Sulawesi.
JOHN TASIRIN: You can see the movement of the animals and then when they move, then suddenly they become new species. Well, not suddenly. After, I don't know, 3,000 - 6,000 years later.
KUHN: Even as Wallace's eyes observed life around him, his mind roamed millions of years back in time to imagine the birth of islands and continents. He also peered into the future. Wallace foretold today's situation in which Sulawesi's unique animals face extinction. He wrote that we have it within our power to save these creatures and not let them, as he put it, perish irrecoverably from the face of the earth uncared for and unknown.
Anthony Kuhn, NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)
MONTAGNE: This is NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.