Bill Knight – January 31
11:56 am
Wed January 30, 2013

The Broken Promise of Fracking

When the movie “Promised Land” came out this month, one was tempted to repeat the tagline from 1972’s horror flick “The Last House on the Left”: “It’s only a movie... It’s only a movie...”

Bill Knight
Bill Knight

But … it’s worse. People on both sides of the fracking debate cringe at “Promised Land,” the Matt Damon drama about fracking advocates trying to get a depressed rural area to sign over drilling rights. Fracking supporters say the film’s unfair; fracking opponents say it doesn’t go far enough.

Maybe it’s no wonder that Illinois’ legislature seems stymied. However, if doing nothing avoids disaster, that’s good. Unlike other states that rushed to comply with industry, Illinois has time. Fracking hasn’t started here, despite thousands of leases signed in downstate’s New Albany shale formation, which extends through Indiana, Kentucky and Tennessee.

Josh Mogerman, a spokesman for the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), said, “We should not start fracking in this state until tight regulations are in place that protect our communities, resources and economy, and we should take the time to ensure those regs avoid the mistakes of our neighbors.”

Fracking is the practice of drilling thousands of feet into rock, fracturing ancient formations, and injecting huge amounts of water, sand and undisclosed chemicals at high pressure to crack open pockets of oil and natural gas trapped there. One well reportedly needs up to 7 million gallons of water, plus 400,000 gallons of additives, from lubricants to solvents. Hazardous chemicals may be used, and, as the journal Nature reported, researchers found that methane leaks resulting from the process pose problems, too.

In Springfield, Senate Bill 3280, a measure of baby steps to begin to regulate fracking, passed in April, but when it moved to the House it was amended to essentially delay fracking until more is known.

Midwest NRDC Director Henry Henderson said, “Standards and sound regulations do not cost jobs. They protect the economy, spur innovation and create manufacturing jobs. A nascent industry under significant public scrutiny, like fracking, cannot move forward if it is plagued by water and air contamination, as well as destruction of resources, property and communities.”

Still, Illinois’ Chamber of Commerce recently issued a glowing analysis, claiming that fracking could mean up to 47,000 new jobs in Illinois and generate $10 billion.

But, Henderson said, “The ‘comprehensive look’ is, by its own description, narrow and divorced from any really meaningful context. The report assumes that shale gas drilling will occur in an accident-free world, without environmental impacts of any kind. That simply has not been the case in any of the other states.”

In fact, the report concedes that fracking is “unproven” and notes that the analysis “does not include,” among other things, “any environmental impacts, costs or benefits,” much less the kinds of jobs they envision.

Illinois Geologic Survey director Don McKay is cautious, saying, “The porosity of the [New Albany] shale is below the threshold of shale in Marcellus [the Pennsylvania formation being drilled]. Marcellus is about 3% porous; ours is more like 1%. Another aspect is that the shale here was deposited in a marine setting, which means it was not buried as deeply, or ‘cooked’ at such depth, so there’s not as much gas created.”

Since a compromise agreeable to all parties seems unlikely, a more sensible approach is to go slow but sure. After all, elsewhere, promised jobs didn’t materialize in Ohio (according to Republican Gov. John Kasich), ground water in Colorado was contaminated, and 100 aquifers in Pennsylvania have been polluted. Even earthquakes have been tied to fracking.

Besides risks to the environment, fracking can pose dangers to the public health, is shrouded in secrecy, has little enforcement where it operates, and could threaten livestock and crops and the people who consume them.

The General Assembly must not get stampeded. Illinois needs a balance between environmental safety and economic development.

Meanwhile, instead of “Promised Land,” check out 2010’s Oscar-nominated documentary “Gasland.”

Bill Knight is a freelance writer. His newspaper columns are archived at billknightcolumn.blogspot.com

The opinions expressed are not necessarily those of Tri States Public Radio or Western Illinois University.